Suet Plus Extra Value Pack, 20 cakes

Our verdict

Synthesized from public specs and 119 buyer mentions. We research and analyze — we don't lab-test.

Compare it with the closest picks

Owner ratings come from Amazon; BirdingScore is our separate research score.

Compare two picks

Tap an unselected chip to compare it with your current right-hand pick — all 4 picks available.

Suet Plus Extra Value Pack, 20 cakesC&S Peanut Delight No Melt Suet, 12 packC&S Woodpecker Suet Treat, 8 packHeath All Season High Energy Suet, 10 pack

Budget pickSuet Plus Extra Value Pack, 20 cakes

4.6 Amazon· $39.99

RecommendedC&S Peanut Delight No Melt Suet, 12 pack

4.6 Amazon· $34.10

BirdingScore

72/100

80/100

Skip it if

You run one feeder occasionally; twenty cakes is a year of feeding for most yards.

Peanuts are a problem in your yard — squirrels and starlings find peanut blends as fast as woodpeckers do.

Cakes per pack

20

12

Blend

High-energy Suet Plus cakes

Rendered beef suet, peanuts, corn, oats, soy oil

No-melt

Melt-resistant formula (manufacturer)

Yes — no-melt dough

Cake weight

—

11.75 oz

Packaging

Individually wrapped, 2 boxes of 10

Case pack

Buy on Amazon· $39.99Buy on Amazon· $34.10

Show buy options for all 4 picks

Suet Plus Extra Value Pack, 20 cakesBuy on Amazon

C&S Peanut Delight No Melt Suet, 12 packBuy on Amazon

C&S Woodpecker Suet Treat, 8 packBuy on Amazon

Heath All Season High Energy Suet, 10 packBuy on Amazon

Suet Plus Extra Value Pack, 20 cakes compared

Compare all 4 picks across 5 specs, scores & buyer sentiment · # is each pick’s rank in Suet Cakes & Refills

Prices & Amazon ratings checked Oct 17, 2026

	This pick · #4 Budget pick Suet Plus Extra Value Pack, 20 cakes 4.6(448)	#1 Recommended C&S Peanut Delight No Melt Suet, 12 pack 4.6(4,490)	#2 Recommended C&S Woodpecker Suet Treat, 8 pack 4.4(484)	#3 Recommended Heath All Season High Energy Suet, 10 pack 4.4(6,579)
Buy	Buy on Amazon $39.99	Buy on Amazon $34.10	Buy on Amazon $18.48	Buy on Amazon $23.99
BirdingScoremethodology →	72/100 Owner satisfaction77 Field value60	80/100 Owner satisfaction81 Field value78	75/100 Owner satisfaction68 Field value95	73/100 Owner satisfaction69 Field value86
Buyer sentiment	Bird PreferenceValue for moneyPet-FriendlyQualityDigestibility Buyers praise bird preference and value for money. Mixed feedback on quality and digestibility. Some flag pet-friendly. Based on 119 buyer mentions	Bird AttractionMelting PointValue for moneyDurability Buyers praise bird attraction and melting point. Mixed feedback on value for money and durability. Based on 844 buyer mentions	Bird PreferenceQualityBird AttractionVarietyMeltingSoftnessMessiness Buyers praise bird preference, quality, bird attraction and variety. Mixed feedback on value for money. Some flag melting and softness. Based on 256 buyer mentions	Not enough buyer reviews yet Only 6,579 ratings so far — too few for a reliable pros-and-cons breakdown.
Skip it if	You run one feeder occasionally; twenty cakes is a year of feeding for most yards.	Peanuts are a problem in your yard — squirrels and starlings find peanut blends as fast as woodpeckers do.	You want the deepest box — this is an eight-cake pack, the smallest case here.	You specifically need a no-melt dough for high summer — this listing is sold as all-season but does not state a no-melt formulation.
Cakes per pack	20	12	8	10
Blend	High-energy Suet Plus cakes	Rendered beef suet, peanuts, corn, oats, soy oil	Suet with nuts, woodpecker-targeted	Bird's Blend, all season high energy
No-melt	Melt-resistant formula (manufacturer)	Yes — no-melt dough	—	—
Cake weight	—	11.75 oz	—	—
Packaging	Individually wrapped, 2 boxes of 10	Case pack	Case pack	Case of 10

The BirdingScore, unpacked

Our published method blends real owner satisfaction with in-category value. No hidden math.

Specifications

Cakes per pack

20

Blend

High-energy Suet Plus cakes

No-melt

Melt-resistant formula (manufacturer)

Packaging

Individually wrapped, 2 boxes of 10

Specs from the manufacturer listing and public product data; confirm the current listing before buying.

Others in Suet Cakes & Refills